# Andy McMullen on Taking Imperfect Action and Building Rental Communities

> Published: 2024-10-24 | Category: podcast-episode | Tags: podcast-episode, real-estate-investing, syndication, build-to-rent, development, mindset

**Guest:** Andy McMullen

Syndicator Andy McMullen shares why imperfect action beats analysis paralysis, how build-to-rent communities create lasting value, and lessons from the 2008 crash.

## Content

Perfect conditions rarely arrive. For most aspiring real estate investors, the biggest obstacle is not the market, the interest rate, or the deal itself. It is the endless waiting for a moment that feels safe enough to begin. On this episode of The REI Agent Podcast, hosts Mattias and Erica explore that exact tension with real estate syndicator and developer Andy McMullen, managing partner of Legacy Acquisitions.

Andy's message is refreshingly direct: take imperfect action, start where you are, and let growth come from the doing rather than the deliberating. Along the way, he shares how his firm builds thriving rental communities, why secondary and tertiary markets hold outsized opportunity, and what the 2008 financial crisis taught him about resilience. Here is what every agent and investor can learn from the conversation.

## Starting Small, Aiming Big

From the outset, Mattias set the tone for the episode. "The goal should always be to improve, to continually get better," he said, a sentiment that echoed through every part of the discussion. Growth, not perfection, is the north star.

Andy embodies that idea. A twenty-year veteran of the real estate industry, he has moved from commercial brokerage into large-scale development, focusing the last several years on multifamily and build-to-rent projects. His path was not a straight line, and he is quick to point out that it did not need to be. What mattered was that he kept moving, kept learning, and kept aiming higher even when he did not have every answer in hand.

## The Paralysis of Perfection

Mattias opened up about a challenge that stops countless would-be investors before they ever begin: the desire for perfection. "Whenever you want to take on something new, there's all this fear surrounding it," he shared. It is a familiar story. People research endlessly, analyze every scenario, and wait for the ideal moment to arrive. But that moment rarely comes, and they end up trapped in a loop of analysis paralysis.

Andy offered a powerful counterpoint drawn from experience. "You don't need to have all the answers before you make a move," he said. "Sometimes, the best thing you can do is take the first step and adjust as you go." The message was unmistakable: real growth comes from taking imperfect action. You gather information by doing, not by waiting, and each step reveals the next one more clearly than any amount of upfront planning ever could.

For agents and investors alike, this reframing is liberating. You do not need certainty to begin. You need a first step, a willingness to learn, and the humility to adjust course as new information arrives.

## Building for the Long Haul

Andy McMullen's business is a testament to the power of long-term thinking. For more than six years, he has focused on transforming raw land into thriving rental communities, prioritizing durable value in an industry where many chase quick wins.

"Our main purpose is building communities and owning them for 5 to 10 years," he explained. "It's about creating sustainable value." That hold-and-build philosophy stands in deliberate contrast to the flip-fast mentality that dominates so much of the investing world. Instead of optimizing for a quick exit, Andy optimizes for stability, cash flow, and the compounding benefits of long-term ownership.

His model centers on building single-family homes and renting them out rather than constructing traditional apartment complexes. By concentrating on secondary and tertiary markets, he has found opportunities to build faster and more affordably than would be possible in saturated primary metros. "We find the places that want us, that welcome our developments, and we bring new opportunities to these communities," he said. It is a strategy that aligns his firm's success with the health of the towns it invests in.

## The Power of Community

For Andy, real estate is not merely a series of transactions. It is about building places people genuinely want to call home. He emphasized the distinct advantages of his build-to-rent developments, which foster a sense of belonging and connection that apartment living often cannot match.

"In our communities, residents have their own space, their backyard, their sense of independence," Andy noted. That lifestyle, a private home with the flexibility of renting, appeals to a growing segment of residents who want the feel of homeownership without the commitment or capital required to buy.

Mattias echoed the point, highlighting the value that thoughtful design delivers to tenants. "You're not just building properties, you're building places where people feel at home," he reflected. For investors, the takeaway is that resident experience and returns are not at odds. Creating environments where people want to stay reduces turnover, supports rents, and builds the kind of durable value Andy prizes.

## Embracing the Lessons of the Past

Andy's journey has not been without hardship. Reflecting on the 2008 financial crisis, he acknowledged the difficult lessons those years delivered. "The market changed dramatically, and we had to adapt," he said. Rather than break him, that period sharpened his instincts and taught him how to navigate uncertainty.

That experience is a large part of what makes him a stronger investor today. He learned to read shifting conditions, to stress-test assumptions, and to build in margins of safety that protect a project when the environment turns. His story is a reminder that every challenge holds the potential for growth. Surviving a downturn is not just about enduring it. It is about extracting the lessons that make you more capable the next time conditions change.

## Mitigating Risk Through Speed and Strategy

A recurring theme in Andy's approach is the disciplined management of development risk. Building in markets that welcome new housing, moving efficiently through the development timeline, and focusing on speed all serve to reduce exposure. The longer a project sits, the more it is exposed to changing rates, rising costs, and shifting demand. By building faster and more affordably in the right markets, Andy compresses that risk window.

For investors evaluating syndications, this is a useful lens. Returns are important, but so is understanding how a sponsor thinks about risk, timelines, and market selection. Andy's emphasis on secondary and tertiary markets, long hold periods, and community-focused development reflects a strategy designed to weather uncertainty rather than gamble on ideal conditions.

## Understanding Syndications and Returns

A significant part of the conversation focused on how everyday investors can participate in projects like Andy's through real estate syndications. Syndication allows a group of investors to pool capital and gain access to larger developments than any of them could pursue alone, while an experienced sponsor handles acquisition, construction, and management.

Andy was candid about both the benefits and the risks. Syndications can offer attractive returns and true passivity for investors who do not want to manage properties themselves, but they also require trust in the sponsor and a clear understanding of the business plan. He walked through the importance of metrics like internal rate of return, or IRR, which measures the annualized return on invested capital over the life of a deal. Rather than fixating on a single headline number, Andy encourages investors to understand how a return is generated, how long their capital will be committed, and what assumptions underpin the projections.

For those interested in participating in his projects, the message mirrored the rest of the episode: do your homework, ask good questions, and then be willing to act. The perfect deal with a perfect operator in perfect conditions does not exist. What exists are solid opportunities with capable sponsors, evaluated honestly and entered with clear eyes.

## Investing in Yourself and Your Vision

The conversation between Mattias, Erica, and Andy was not only about financial success. It was about personal growth and resilience. The episode served as a powerful reminder that success in real estate is a journey rather than a destination, a continuous process of learning, adjusting, and striving to be better.

"It's not about being perfect, it's about showing up, improving, and staying in the game," Mattias put it. Andy's advice to aspiring investors was simple yet profound: "Don't wait for the stars to align. Start with what you have, where you are, and keep moving forward."

## Key Takeaways for Investors and Agents

Andy McMullen's appearance on The REI Agent Podcast leaves listeners with several principles worth applying. Taking imperfect action beats waiting for perfect conditions, because momentum and learning come from doing. Long-term ownership and community building create sustainable value that outlasts short-term market swings. Secondary and tertiary markets can offer speed, affordability, and welcome that crowded primary markets cannot. And resilience, forged through challenges like the 2008 crisis, is what separates investors who last from those who fade.

If you wait for perfect conditions, you will miss countless opportunities. Whether you are a seasoned investor or just starting out, the time to take action is now. Learn from every experience, build connections, and keep your eye on the bigger picture. As Andy put it, "Real estate isn't just about buildings, it's about creating lasting impact."

## Connect With Andy McMullen

To learn more about Andy McMullen and his work in real estate development and syndication, connect through Legacy Acquisitions:

- Website: [Legacy Acquisitions](https://legacyacquisitions.com/)

For more inspiring conversations with top agents and investors who are building wealth and living well through real estate, visit [reiagent.com](https://reiagent.com/) and subscribe to The REI Agent Podcast.

## Related Episode

This post is based on Episode 37 of the WELLthy Investor Podcast.
- [Listen to Episode 37](https://reiagent.com/episodes/)

## Links

- [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VB-hay9v_pk)
- [Full HTML version](https://reiagent.com/blog/andy-mcmullen-imperfect-action-build-to-rent-communities/)